EXPERTS are undecided what this 5 lb 1 oz mystery fish caught by Nathan Hewitt actually is!


nathan hewwit

Caught from Newhay Lakes near Selby, North Yorkshire,  a true scientific examination isn’t possible on the mystery catch due to the fins being hidden.

Local Nathan used two 8 mm luncheon meat cubes and it was fine reward for a few blank sessions with a pal.

Fish ID expert Dr Mark Everard said: “I can’t give you anything remotely scientific on this for the usual reason (hands all over the fish and fins collapsed), but it does look odd! If I had to put money on it, I’d say a chub-roach hybrid – rare but they do occur.”

Other suggestions were that it’s an ide or even an asp, or even a hybrid of one of them. A giant asp featured in Angler’s Mail magazine a few months ago.

This is just a short version of the full story that appeared in the printed magazine. Get the magazine every week for top tips, big news, best products, and venues that are in form.

CAUGHT A BIG FISH? Email photos and details exclusively to: – you could star in the magazine and win great prizes.